Controversy Erupts Over Trump-Era US Travel Advisory Labeling India as High-Risk for Crime and Terrorism
Washington/New Delhi — The Trump administration is facing criticism over what many are calling a “hypocritical and exaggerated” travel advisory for Americans living in or planning to visit India. The U.S. State Department has placed India under its Level 2: Exercise Increased Caution advisory category, citing elevated risks of crime, terrorism, and sexual violence — a move that has sparked backlash from Indian leaders and observers.
Despite referring to India as a “trusted partner,” the advisory paints a starkly negative picture. It warns American travelers of violent crimes such as sexual assault occurring even at popular tourist destinations. According to the advisory, “Rape is one of the fastest growing crimes in India,” and travelers should remain vigilant, especially in public places, markets, and near government buildings — areas frequently targeted in past attacks.
Contradictions in US Stance Toward India
Critics have called out the double standards in the Trump-era foreign policy, pointing to how India is hailed as a strategic ally in defense and economic relations, yet portrayed as a dangerous destination for U.S. citizens. This contradiction, they argue, undermines diplomatic goodwill and paints an unbalanced picture of India’s safety landscape.
Adding to the criticism, U.S. authorities have specifically advised against travel to Jammu and Kashmir, citing terrorism and civil unrest. The advisory points to sporadic violence in the Kashmir Valley, including in popular destinations like Srinagar, Gulmarg, and Pahalgam. It also mentions the risks along the Line of Control (LoC), where conflict between Indian and Pakistani forces has historically flared.
Northeast and Naxal-Affected Areas Also Flagged
The U.S. has extended its caution to India’s Northeast and Naxal-affected regions. The advisory warns travelers of Maoist (Naxalite) activity in areas stretching from eastern Maharashtra and northern Telangana to parts of West Bengal, including states like Bihar, Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Odisha, and Meghalaya.
Particularly controversial was the mention of Meghalaya, which drew sharp criticism from local leaders. Deputy Chief Minister Preston Tynsong condemned the advisory, stating, “Meghalaya is one of the safest places in the world for tourists. It’s unfortunate and disheartening that the U.S. has categorized our state in this way. We question the source of their information.”
Additional Restrictions and Legal Warnings
The advisory also warns U.S. citizens about legal regulations in India, such as the prohibition of satellite phones and unlicensed GPS devices, which could lead to fines of up to $200,000 or imprisonment of up to three years. Travelers are advised not to travel alone — especially women — and to make sure they have comprehensive travel insurance.
Mounting Diplomatic Discontent
The tone and content of the advisory have sparked broader questions about U.S. diplomatic consistency. While the Trump administration publicly reaffirmed strong ties with India, such advisories risk eroding trust and cooperation between the two countries.
Indian authorities have yet to issue an official response from the central government, but public sentiment and state-level pushback — especially from leaders like Tynsong — indicate growing frustration over what many see as an unfair portrayal of India’s safety and stability.
As global travel resumes and international relations continue to evolve, advisories such as these play a key role in shaping perceptions. However, when based on questionable or outdated assessments, they can damage more than just tourism — they can strain bilateral relations.